Sony Alpha A7S Digital Camera Review
A niche camera in a family of niche cameras
Sony shook up the camera world last year with the introduction of the first true full-frame mirrorless cameras. The A7 and A7R weren't perfect, but both models represented a huge leap forward for photographers. For full-frame shooters accustomed to the tyranny of heavy, pro-grade DSLRs, Sony seemingly found the holy grail—delivering a pro-quality sensor in a lightweight body.
The hype machine in enthusiast circles went into overdrive, making these cameras seem like the end-all-be-all of digital photography. In the cold, grey light of dawn, though, the truth was that both models were clearly first-generation products with plenty of issues. Warts and all, it was easy to see the potential there, and the 36-megapixel A7R did well enough to earn our coveted Editors' Choice award.
While we were eager to see how Sony would follow up on the A7/A7R's success, we didn't think it would come so soon. The third entry into the A7 series, the Sony Alpha A7S (MSRP $2,499.99) dropped last year seemingly out of nowhere. It's not a second-generation product so much as an answer to every enthusiast photographer's favorite thought experiment. What if a manufacturer dialed back the megapixels in favor of larger pixels? If you took the A7's 24-megapixel sensor and cut it down to 12MP with pixels twice as big, what could you do? Well, it turns out you can basically see in the dark.
It's not the cheapest camera in the world, and it doesn't fix the major issues from the A7/A7R—focus speed, battery life, lens availability—but it does add incredible low light sensitivity and (with some hangups) 4K video shooting. Is that worth it to you? How much would you pay for a camera that can see in the darkest corners of the earth like it's no big deal?
Design & Handling
A mostly-good combination of elements that still lacks chemistry.
There's little doubt that the A7 cameras are groundbreaking models. As the first mirrorless full-frame system, Sony designed them to look the part of a modern trendsetter. Unfortunately, there are times when the A7S's striking design gets in the way of simple ergonomics.
As with other cameras, controlling the A7S begins with the grip. It's large and accommodating compared to other Sony cameras, reminding us of a more rigid version of the the original NEX-7's grip. Our only concern this time around is how well it'll hold up with a full-frame lens system in mind. Adapt a lens, or mount something like your typical Canon/Nikon 24-70mm f/2.8 to the A7S and it becomes incredibly unstable. Even with smaller prime lenses, the A7S feels heavy and weighs down your wrists.
It's understandable that the A7 family is stuck serving two masters as far as design goes—it wants to be a little retro and compact, while also needing to appeal to pro shooters who will want to use all kinds of big glass on it. As it stands, we hope that the petite A7 series grows up just a skosh in future iterations to accommodate serious, professional users and hopefully some of the bigger glass Sony has on the current FE lens roadmap.
Thankfully, the A7S is otherwise just like the A7/A7R, controlling more like Sony's Alpha line of DSLRs than earlier NEX cameras. Three control dials, plenty of customizability, and a dedicated exposure compensation dial make shooting with the A7S relatively painless. The refined menu system makes more sense than some past Sony cameras, even though some options can be a little hard to decipher (it isn't immediately obvious what exactly "Audio Signals" changes, for instance).
Our biggest beef with the A7S remains the placement of the very important menu button. This critical button is the only way to get inside the full-blown menu, and it's on the far left side of the camera, exactly where your right hand can't reach it. While a quick menu makes up for this shortcoming a little bit, you miss out on so many other options you might need to access.
Even though our time with the A7S reminded us of the shortcomings of its brethren, it also reinforced how much the two other A7 models got right. The A7S is a competently designed compact camera with a nice set of controls. Its rear LCD and built-in EVF are still top-of-the-line. Overall, it's an experience that, once you get used to its quirks, is almost as good as it should be.
Sensor & Sensitivity
Not actually a forgotten Jane Austen novel
Sony has become an absolute powerhouse in the imaging business, but the company's success isn't due to world-beating camera sales. Mostly, it's thanks to the company's amazing sensors. Since 2010, Sony-manufactured sensors have powered such great cameras as the Olympus OM-D E-M5, Pentax K-3, Panasonic Lumix FZ1000, and even Nikon's D800. Of course, Sony saves some of the most unique chips for the company's own models.
When launching the A7 and A7R last year, Sony made it pretty clear what these cameras were designed to accomplish. The A7R, with its 36-megapixel sensor (sans optical low pass filter), was slow and loud, but it is the sharpest of the bunch. The A7, packing a 24-megapixel sensor with on-chip phase detection, was designed with speed in mind. Bearing both of these distinct cameras in mind, what the heck does the A7S bring to the table?
After all, 12 megapixels is way less than 24 or 36, so it can't be that good can it? That's where you'd be absolutely incorrect. While the pixel count is significantly lower than its sister cameras, the A7S rocks at low-light shooting. Since the sensor is the same size with far fewer pixels, individual photosites are bigger and light collection is more effective. Smaller pixels, without some kind of compensation, generally just perform worse than bigger pixels. Having greater resolution can offset this to some degree, but when light is very, very limited the larger pixels will perform better almost every time.
Due to its lower-resolution sensor and significantly bigger pixels, the A7S is the sensitive child of the A7 family. Its ISO sensitivities range from 100 all the way up to 409,600—that's four more stops of sensitivity up the scale. A shot that would require an eight-second exposure at ISO 100 can be just as bright (albeit much noisier) taken at ISO 409,600 with an exposure of just 1/500th of a second. That's ridiculous.
And, y'know what? These sensitivities aren't completely unusable, either. In our tests, we didn't see aggressive banding until roughly ISO 25,600 and only in low frequency scenes without much detail. We'd say that you'd be absolutely safe limiting auto ISO to 12,800 and letting the camera choose for you. You might not want to shoot in color at higher ISOs due to pronounced color shift and chroma noise, but for black and white conversions, you can essentially take stills long after other photographers have given up hope.
This special asset pays off doubly for video. The lower megapixel count makes it so the sensor can shoot in dimly-lit scenes incredibly well. Using only five lux of indirect ambient light, we recorded the above footage of our standard still life, and were suitably impressed by what we saw. In our sensitivity test, this camera didn't even bat an eye, never dropping below 50 IRE until well after even our pro-quality light meters stopped being able to even measure the lux level.
Before you buy the Sony Alpha A7S, take a look at these other interchangeable lens cameras.
Some new abilities that'll appeal mostly to videographers
On top of what you get out of the A7 and A7R, the A7S has a few unique mutant powers of its own. This is normally the area where we'd talk about NFC, WiFi, creative filters, and the like. If you want to read about what you can expect from the A7S, we recommend that you check out our A7R review for what the entire family includes. Of special note is the excellent EVF, which is large, bright, detailed, and as comfortable to use as an optical viewfinder—moreso if you are shooting in extreme low light.
The most amazing new feature is something we've seen in some competing cameras—a completely digital, silent shutter. By going silent, the A7S almost becomes a magical device. Memories of the A7R's loud, clacky shutter melt away immediately when you realize that you're silently snapping away using a full frame digital camera. It's uncanny, and it's quieter than even the quiet capture modes on Canon and Nikon cameras.
When the A7S was introduced at NAB, the press really focused on its 4K shooting abilities, usually by burying the obvious caveat that you need an external recorder that isn't even on the market right now. The only recorders that are compatible with the A7S's 4K-via-HDMI output at the time of this writing are designed for studio usage (read: you need to be near a wall outlet). Until the Atomos Shogun makes an appearance later on this year, it's not feasible to bring the A7S on location without a car and a power inverter.
The funny thing is that we know that the A7S's Bionz X processor can handle 4K output directly onto an SD card, as a similar chip powers the AX100 4K camcorder. And even once the necessary recorders hit the market you'll still be limited to 8-bit 4K video, something that the Panasonic Lumix GH4 can record internally. To an SD card. Yeah, we were disappointed, too.
While we can see that videographers would be interested in this camera for some scenarios, not everyone is shooting Barry Lyndon. For the money, you could net a Blackmagic Cinema 4K camera which has a global shutter and internal 4K recording. It's a better value proposition, as long as you're not making documentaries about bats or a found-footage horror film about molemen.
Looking beyond 4K, this camera is also great at shooting good ol' 1080/60p, thanks to its direct sensor readout (no lines on the sensor are skipped). HD video is noticeably sharper than what we saw from the A7 and A7R in both bright and low light, as there's far less downsampling that needs to be done. And there's also plenty of other video-centric features carried over from the A7/A7R such as Zebra patterns, audio monitoring, and mic and headphone jacks. The result isn't studio-ready like the new Blackmagic offerings or the GH4 with the YAGH interface unit, but for run 'n gun shooting in available light, the A7S is simply unrivaled.
A superlative sensor tethered to a less-than-stellar AF system
After putting it through our lab tests, we don't have any deal-breaking complaints about the A7S. It's a competent camera that can make excellent pictures and superb video. Our concerns mainly come down to a couple of annoying issues. While other mirrorless cameras can boast phenomenal autofocus speed, the A7S is clearly burdened by a lackluster AF system.
Just like the A7R, the contrast-based system offered here simply doesn't track moving subjects well at all. It's fuzzy and imprecise and the only remedy we could find was stopping down the aperture or shooting with wider lenses. Compared to cameras from a few years ago we could probably have given the A7S a pass here, but cameras like the Olympus OM-D E-M1, Fujifilm X-T1, and Panasonic GH4 are all much faster. For pros used to fantastic, reliable focus systems from the likes of Canon and Nikon, the A7S feels very sluggish.
In our labs, however, the A7S really knocked our socks off. Even though we continue to find fault with Sony's JPEG engine, with all its oversharpening and overly aggressive noise reduction, the pure performance on tap couldn't help but buoy this camera's scores in most areas.
Like we mentioned previously, the ISO sensitivities are incredible. But, what's more is that this camera holds on to usable dynamic range better than just about every other camera on the market today. We measured 1.11 stops of high DR using Imatest at—get this—ISO 102400. At the same sensitivity using Nikon's D4S, Imatest reported no stops of high DR. This may be due to some creativity on Sony's part with how the A7S records RAW files, however.
Video was another bright spot—pun absolutely intended. On top of nearly having night vision, the A7S, with direct sensor readout, preserves detail very well in both bright and low light. In fact, the two tests were almost indistinguishable from each other, which means that even at 60 lux, you can pull about the same amount of resolution from a scene. Discounting the lack of in-camera 4K recording, this should be a pretty solid option for straightforward 1080/60p X-AVC S HD. We'll be exploring this camera's video shooting capabilities more in-depth once we can get our hands on a 4K-capable external recorder, so check back real soon.
A final performance gripe that's definitely worth noting is that the A7S sucks down battery like a thirsty runner rehydrating after a 5K. When shooting with the A7S, you can watch the battery meter run down percentage by percentage with each shutter click. The problem is bad enough that Sony has bundled the A7S with a second battery that, if you're shooting intensely for a day, you're going to want to bring with you.
Derivative, but distinctly different
We weren't expecting to like this version of the A7 nearly as much as we did. Given the strengths of its stablemates, there was the sense that the A7S was something of a one-trick pony. But, what a world of difference a sensor swap makes.
While we're disappointed that we weren't yet able to test the A7S's much-touted 4K video feature, the camera's still shooting narrative couldn't be any clearer: never before has so much shooting latitude been crammed into such a small camera. It's a marvel of engineering that doesn't end up being as gimmicky as we predicted in the real world. Armed with some great lenses, this camera becomes an image-making tool that can handle practically any lighting situation extremely well. It isn't perfect, but if you don't need super-fast continuous shooting or incredibly high resolution, it is a functional low-light alternative to the Canon EOS 1D X and Nikon D4S for less than half the price.
The biggest buzzkill remains focusing speed. This little puppy just can't keep up with other flagship mirrorless cameras, or with big full-frame DSLRs to save its life. For all but simple, single-point AF, the A7 cameras just aren't there yet. It's easy to speculate that the focusing bugaboo will be resolved with firmware or with future hardware iterations, but as it stands today, it's just not good enough for the price you're paying. We feel like Sony traded on its usually excellent autofocus in order to push the FE-mount cameras in a different direction, mostly to the cameras' detriment.
If we had to point out another, less important drawback, it's the comparatively low resolution of the sensor. Sure, 12 megapixels was considered great just a few years ago, but it does feel limited if you've been shooting with 20+ and 30+ megapixel cameras lately. That said, you should consider the trade-off. Because what you gain in return is the flexibility of a photographic yogi thanks to the A7S's high ISO prowess. It won't do anything if you're trying (and failing) to focus on moving subjects, but it's a sensitivity matched only by the Nikon D4S currently.
The price is undoubtedly steep, but keep in mind that there is no other camera that can do what the A7S does. Even though we wouldn't recommend this to just anyone (it's a deep cut from Sony, even within the already niche A7 series), if you want a sensitive full-frame sensor inside a compact camera, the A7S just can't be beat. With a couple of the already-legendary FE prime lenses in your camera bag, the A7S will take you further than most other digital cameras you can buy today.
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. However, our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.