Advertisement. The page you requested will display in seconds.
Advertisement. The page you requested will display in seconds.
Last year was rather yawn-inducing for travel-zoom cameras. While Canon's SX260 HS was eventually crowned the best of the bunch, we were really hoping the company would bring something exciting to the table for 2013's travel zoom, the SX280 HS (MSRP $329.99).
Nope. The SX280 is a safe, minor update over the camera it replaces. What's worse, although a few tweaks are for the best, this camera is weighed down by some drawbacks that cause it to underperform the previous model.
The SX280 is both pocketable and comfortable to use, an impressive achievement for any compact camera design. The smooth paneling slips easily into and out of a jeans pocket, but a thin vertical protrusion has been included on the right side of the front panel, giving the middle finger a perfect place to latch onto.
On the rear panel, the vertically oriented mode dial is not only sturdy and stays in place, but it gives your thumb a comfortable place to wedge itself in. We're amazed that this simple design handles so well without resorting to any sticky, rubberized surfaces.
It's not all good news, though. The dual-function directional pad / rotating dial is fine for pressing but lousy for rotating. The wheel is thin, chintzy, and prone to inadvertently activating mute or some other setting while scrolling through the menu.
The all-important optical zoom lever is also awfully imprecise. You might be able to live with this drawback during everyday shooting, but if you ever need very specific framing (portraits, for example), you'll find the hair-trigger zoom lever has an obnoxious dead zone. Finally, we were disappointed by the SX280's battery life, which Canon rates at only 210 shots on a single charge, or 260 when using Eco mode. That's quite a bit lower than other cameras in this class, and probably won't even last you an entire day of shooting.
Just like last year's model, the SX280's unremarkable image sensor tops out at only 12.1 megapixels. In fact we might be tempted to believe this is the very same chip used in the SX260, however a few performance downgrades left us scratching our heads.
While the SX280's lens construction and specifications seem identical to the SX260, sharpness has inexplicably dropped off. The test results we got weren't exactly uncommon for a camera of this class, but we did expect more from Canon, and more from the successor to last year's best travel zoom.
Color accuracy is a similar story: acceptable in the context of the entire industry, but poor for a Canon. This is a manufacturer that consistently delivers highly accurate cameras even at the entry level, yet the SX280 offers only mediocrity in this test.
It's true that the SX280's new noise reduction algorithm does eliminate more noise than last year's version, but only because the software is so needlessly aggressive. While the SX280 does offer an additional ISO level over the SX260, the SX280 blurs images starting at ISO 800 and continuing up to the max. Since noise reduction cannot be tweaked or turned off, you're stuck with this limitation.
White balance accuracy isn't enough of a factor to save the SX280's already-disappointing overall performance. Nevertheless, the SX280's automatic white balance system was remarkably efficient, and the custom white balance system was near perfect. Unless you're shooting under incandescent light, automatic white balance is perfectly sufficient, and a custom reading will correct any color temperature errors you may encounter under challenging light.
We're not formally scoring image stabilization these days, but our hands-on experience was more than enough to realize the system works very well. Framing is steady even at full 20x, and this is even more true when shooting video, where the stabilizer works nearly as well as a tripod.
The SX280's video output didn't score well in our lab tests, but truth be told we were pretty pleased with our sample footage from the field. Like stills, video sharpness wasn't what it should've been, and to our surprise we even spotted a few white balance errors. But outside, in daylight, shooting more interesting subjects than test charts, the SX280 proved itself a capable enough video companion.
GPS functionality has been held over from last year, allowing EXIF tagging of each shot with geographical coordinates. Of course, this comes at the cost of even more battery life, dinging the SX280's already-anemic capacity. WiFi connectivity is this year's other big add, just in case you need to share your photos with the rest of the world instantaneously. Unfortunately, while the interface works, it does so within the confines of Canon's existing menu system (which is great for photography, but not so great for wireless encryption keys). The result is a WiFi solution that seems outdated compared to competition like Samsung, which is already shipping cameras with full-blown Android on board.
The best travel-zoom camera of 2012 has been replaced by a mediocre stand-in, and Canon has voluntarily relinquished the top spot in this important area of the market.
Aside from improved handling characteristics and the addition of WiFi features, the SX280 is almost entirely inferior to its predecessor. Sharpness—worse. Color accuracy—worse. Noise reduction—worse. And the performance metrics that didn't decrease have largely stayed the same. Video shooting is decent, but no better than the SX260. Dynamic range has been improved, but not by much. Chromatic aberration is less severe, but the apparent tradeoff is poor sharpness.
We could almost consider the possibility of overlooking all this, if the camera's most important addition—WiFi—was impressive. It isn't. Over a full year has passed since WiFi first started cropping up in camera bodies, and the SX280's implementation is cumbersome and dated by comparison.
If you already own an SX260, or any decent travel-zoom, there's no reason in the world to upgrade to this one. In fact, if you're a brand new customer, we do recommend shopping around for the older, better SX260.
News and Features
The K-3 finally gets the makeover it deserves.
These lenses come with a neat trick—OLED displays
Weather-sealed and compact, this Fuji is ready to grab landscapes.
Sony brings advanced features to two affordable CyberShots.
Wearable action cams? 4K pro camcorder? GH4 firmware? Yes!
Already solid point-and-shoots get an update.
Getting up close and personal with our little friends in the backyard.
Chef Jacques la Merde presents junk food in artisanal fashion.
With two new cameras, Canon's 4K lineup is more versatile than ever.
Sign up to get the latest news and reviews only available to our email subscribers
Thank you for subscribing!